Skip to content
What is a HAZOP? A Guide to Navigating Complex Processes
In the United States, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the United Kingdom/European Union Health & Safety legislative bodies require Process Hazard Analysis (PHA) to identify, reduce, and manage workplace hazards.
HAZOP, an abbreviation for Hazard and Operability Study, is globally acknowledged as a technique for process hazard analysis and identification and is integral to risk management.
Although HAZOP studies are effective, they are also resource-intensive and complex. For simpler processes with clearly identified hazards, methods such as checklists, What-If analysis, or HAZIDs are often more practical. However, HAZOP is generally preferred for more intricate systems.
Workplace risks, whether physical, chemical, or inherent, can lead to harm and include factors such as flammability, toxicity, and environmental impact. Recognizing these hazards is the first step in developing a strong safety strategy. The focus of the HAZOP study is to identify hazards in your processes that could lead to operational issues.
This first of this three-part blog series on the importance of HAZOP studies will provide an overview of key terminology, explore critical aspects of the HAZOP study, delve into why it’s a necessary undertaking, and provide examples of how this methodology can seamlessly integrate into any stage of your process safety journey.
HAZOP Terminology: Unravelling the Methodology
Before exploring the details of a Hazard and Operability Study, it’s important to first understand the key terminology related to process hazards. Identifying the types and potential severity of these hazards is fundamental to developing an effective safety strategy.
Process Hazards vs. Non-Process Hazards
In Process Hazard Analysis (PHA), a distinction is made between process hazards and non-process hazards. Process hazards, which are inherent to the operation, include factors like pressure, temperature, and level control. Non-process hazards, while still significant, fall outside the scope of PHA. These include workplace safety risks, such as slips, trips, falls, and improper use of personal protective equipment (PPE).
Process Parameters and Design Intent
Understanding the details of process parameters is essential. Whether it’s a reactor vessel, heat exchanger, or storage tank, knowing the design intent is key. Changes from the intended design, such as reduced heat exchange efficiency or uncontrolled fluid temperatures, can highlight potential hazards. It is important to recognize what changes in the process could lead to problems that need to be addressed during the hazard analysis.
Process Risk: Evaluating Consequences
Process risk looks at the potential outcomes of identified hazards. This includes assessing the severity of incidents like overflows in containment systems or chemical spills, and understanding the potential impact on personnel, equipment, and the environment. This evaluation is crucial for understanding the risks associated with each hazard.
Process Hazard Analysis and Methodologies for Safety
PHA is the main approach used to identify and assess hazards. One methodology used within this broader approach focuses on identifying operability issues in systems. Other techniques, such as HAZIDs, What-If analysis, and checklists, are also applicable depending on the complexity of the process.
It’s important to note that in the United States, there are no specific requirements for a set methodology, allowing flexibility to choose the most appropriate approach based on the situation. When selecting the right method, the following factors should be considered:
- The complexity of the process
- The hazards inherent to the materials being processed
- The experience of the team conducting the risk assessment
- Existing company policies and procedures for risk assessment
Essential Information for PHA Studies
To conduct a thorough PHA, comprehensive information is required, including detailed data about chemicals, processes, and equipment. Tools like Process and Instrumentation Diagrams (P&IDs), process flow diagrams, and energy balances provide a clear overview. Additionally, understanding the operating limits for parameters such as temperature, pressure, and flow rate, as well as the safe operating conditions of equipment and piping, including maximum allowable working pressure, vacuum ratings, and failure temperatures, helps in accurately estimating the severity and likelihood of potential hazards.
HAZOP Study: A Structured Deep Dive
Unlike broader risk assessment and hazard analysis methods, HAZOP dissects the intricacies of a system piece by piece, focusing on each equipment unit.
This detailed examination involves scrutinizing every parameter against the designed intent of the equipment and understanding potential failure modes. The result is a comprehensive understanding of the system’s vulnerabilities and potential issues.
Guide words:The foundation of analysis
HAZOP’s efficacy hinges on the implementation of guide words. These guidewords serve as the touchstones for the analysis to prompt and identify potential deviations. Whether it’s ‘more,’ ‘less,’ ‘no,’ or ‘as well as,’ these guide words steer the discussion towards potential scenarios that could compromise safety. This approach ensures that no stone is left unturned in identifying possible workplace hazards.
The power of a multi-disciplinary HAZOP team
A diverse and knowledgeable set of HAZOP team members are key. A single individual cannot grasp the complexities of a process entirely. Thus, a multi-disciplinary team becomes the linchpin of a successful HAZOP analysis.
The team comprises of a facilitator/chair, design engineering, test engineering, safety experts, maintenance personnel, and operations professionals. This amalgamation of expertise ensures a high-level, holistic perspective, leaving no aspect of the process unexamined.
Equipment-centric analysis
HAZOPs zoom in on the intricacies of each piece of equipment. By examining the parameters specific to the designed intent of the equipment, the study can uncover potential failure points that might be overlooked in broader analyses. This methodical examination not only identifies hazards but also provides insights into how these hazards could manifest under different conditions.
Navigating the Unknown: Why HAZOP?
When faced with a new process, unfamiliar chemicals, or major updates to established existing processes, conducting a HAZOP in the early stages proves invaluable. It serves as a proactive measure, aiding in the design of processes that are inherently safe. The systematic examination of each parameter against the designed intent of equipment ensures a thorough understanding of potential pitfalls and enhances the safety profile of the process.
Procedural precision
Beyond its primary focus to identify hazards, HAZOP also serves as a procedural development tool. By scrutinizing procedures, it minimizes opportunities for human errors. This meticulous approach ensures that operational protocols are written in a way that mitigates human failure. Potential causes examined during a procedural review include performing steps out of order, skipping steps, performing an appropriate action on an incorrect element, performing an incorrect action on the appropriate element, and performing actions too early or late in the process.
Systematic safety oversight: Ensuring operability
One of the core utilities of HAZOP lies in its ability to act as a systematic track for operability. It questions the safeguards in place and evaluates their relevance to potential scenarios. This analysis prevents scenarios where over-instrumentation may lead to faults, trips, and operability concerns or, conversely, situations where under-instrumentation could result in undetected failures until a catastrophic event occurs.
Proof of due diligence
HAZOP isn’t merely a process; it’s proof of due diligence. By undertaking a comprehensive HAZOP study, organizations showcase their commitment to identifying and addressing as many hazards as possible. It stands as an acceptable form of Process Hazard Analysis (PHA), providing assurance to regulatory bodies and stakeholders that all necessary steps have been taken to ensure safety.
Adapting to change: Confirming modifications
As processes evolve with new equipment, materials, or procedures, HAZOP plays a critical role by ensuring that process modifications don’t introduce new hazard scenarios. This adaptability confirms that changes within the design process align with safety protocols, offering a layer of assurance against unforeseen risks.
As industries evolve, the adaptability of HAZOP ensures a proactive and comprehensive approach to identifying, mitigating, and addressing potential hazards.
HAZOP and Your Process Lifecycle
Front-End Engineering Design (FEED)
During the Front-End Engineering Design (FEED) phase, when design decisions are taking shape, conducting a HAZOP is a prudent step. This early analysis allows for the ranking of potential technologies against each other, unveiling the comparative risks and hazards associated with each option.
Dive into detailed design: Sanity check
As the design progresses and reaches a detailed point, a HAZOP serves as a crucial sanity check. This stage ensures that the safeguards in place are not just on paper but are effective in addressing the identified concerns. It’s a moment of reflection and validation, confirming that the safety measures align with the intricacies of the evolving design.
Managing change: A continuous evaluation
Change is inevitable in any dynamic process environment. Anytime a design change is in the offing, particularly during the finalization of the design, a HAZOP should be on the checklist. A Management of Change process should trigger a HAZOP review, especially if the change is substantial.
This ensures that new risks are identified and the HAZOP is updated accordingly.
Pre-commissioning vigilance: Ensuring sense in procedures
Before the green light for commissioning is given, a HAZOP can be completed during pre-commissioning activities. With construction completed and startup imminent, this analysis ensures that commissioning procedures align with safety protocols. It’s a preventive measure to catch any discrepancies before the process goes live.
Normal operation audits: Periodic vigilance
HAZOP isn’t a one-time affair; it demands periodic attention. Regular audits during normal operations are essential. This ensures that the facility is operating within the safety parameters identified during the HAZOP study.
In the United States, OSHA dictates that all processes that fall under the guidance of the PSM standard be reviewed and revalidated on a five-year basis. Furthermore, if an incident occurs, there might be a requirement to update the HAZOP at a greater frequency than the standard five years as part of the required corrective actions.
Navigating Safely Through Complexity
Hazard and Operability Studies (HAZOPs) stand as a testament to the commitment to safeguarding operations.
The complexity of HAZOPs necessitates a thoughtful selection of tools based on the complexity of the operation and the level of detail required for hazard identification. For more straightforward hazards, methodologies such as checklists, what-if analyses, and HAZIDs may be more fitting.
HAZOP’s structured deep dive into each equipment unit, foundation in guide words, and reliance on a multi-disciplinary team ensure a comprehensive examination. It serves not only as a hazard identification tool but as a procedural development tool, contributing to a safer working environment by minimizing human errors.
Throughout the process lifecycle, from Front-End Engineering Design (FEED) to pre-commissioning and normal operation audits, HAZOP remains a vigilant guardian against unforeseen risks. Its continuous evaluation during changes and updates confirms that safety protocols align with evolving processes.
HAZOP is not just a methodology; it’s a strategic choice to navigate the complexity of industrial processes safely. As industries evolve, the enduring relevance and adaptability of HAZOP ensure that safety remains at the forefront of operations.
You can also watch our webinar on Importance of HAZOP Studies https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEfPa3YzY_s
