sigma-hse-logo
Search
Search
sigma-hse-logo
sigma-hse-logo-expanded
sigma-hse-logo-expanded

Our Solutions: Consulting

Layers of Protection Analysis(LOPA)

An engineer in a safety helmet holding a clipboard, standing in an industrial facility. The image symbolizes the concept of Layers of Protection Analysis (LOPA), focusing on risk assessment and safety management.

What is Layers of Protection Analysis (LOPA)

The structured approach of Layers of Protection Analysis begins by assigning a numerical value to the initiating event frequency for each hazard scenario. This frequency undergoes modification based on enabling event probabilities, such as:

  • The probability of ignition sources being present
  • Personnel occupancy rates in affected areas
  • Environmental conditions that could influence the scenario


When implementing Layers of Protection Analysis, practitioners examine independent safeguards, which form distinct protection layers within the process. Each safeguard undergoes evaluation based on its probability of failure on demand (PFD), measuring its reliability in preventing or mitigating potential consequences. These independent safeguards work together to create a comprehensive safety system that reduces overall risk.

Essential Steps in Layers of Protection Analysis (LOPA)

Layers of Protection Analysis follows a methodical sequence to assess and enhance safety measures. These steps guide organizations through risk evaluation, safeguard assessment, and implementation of protective measures. Each step builds upon the previous one to create a comprehensive safety analysis framework.

  • Select and define hazard scenarios from Process Hazard Analysis (PHA) findings
  • Identify and calculate the frequency of initiating events
  • Determine enabling conditions that affect scenario probability
  • Document existing independent protection layers and their effectiveness
  • Calculate risk by combining initiating event frequency and protection layer data
  • Compare results against risk tolerance criteria
  • Develop recommendations for additional safeguards if needed
  • Prepare LOPA worksheets and documentation
  • Review findings with stakeholders and technical teams
  • Create implementation plans for approved recommendations

Understanding the Layers of Protection Analysis Methodology

LOPA begins by assigning a numerical value to the initiating event frequency for each hazard scenario. This frequency undergoes modification based on enabling event probabilities, such as:

  • The probability of ignition sources being present
  • Personnel occupancy rates in affected areas
  • Environmental conditions that could influence the scenario


The methodology then examines independent safeguards, which form distinct layers of protection within the process. Each safeguard undergoes evaluation based on its probability of failure on demand (PFD), measuring its reliability in preventing or mitigating potential consequences. These independent safeguards work together to create a comprehensive safety system that reduces the overall risk of hazardous events.

Risk Assessment and Reduction Process

During hazard scenario assessment, Layers of Protection Analysis (LOPA) practitioners calculate the modified risk level by considering:

  1. Initial event frequency
  2. Enabling factors
  3. Effectiveness of protection layers
  4. Impact of independent safeguards


This calculated risk undergoes comparison with predetermined acceptable risk criteria. When gaps exist between the acceptable and calculated risk levels, safety professionals determine the necessary risk reduction measures. These measures often include implementing additional independent safeguards or enhancing existing protection layers.

Benefits of Layers of Protection Analysis

The implementation of Layers of Protection Analysis offers several significant advantages:

  • Facilitates comprehensive evaluation of specific hazard scenarios identified as high-priority
  • Validates the independence and effectiveness of existing safeguards
  • Provides quantitative justification for resource allocation in safety improvements
  • Supports data-driven decision-making in risk management
  • Enhances overall process safety management systems

Industry Standards and Best Practices

Standards governing Layers of Protection Analysis align with international safety requirements and industry best practices for Process Hazard Analysis. The methodology incorporates guidance from organizations such as the Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS) and the International Society of Automation (ISA). These organizations provide detailed frameworks and technical guidelines that help companies implement effective risk reduction strategies.

The implementation of LOPA follows structured protocols established by multiple international bodies. For example, IEC 61511 standards outline requirements for safety instrumented systems, which form key independent safeguards in many LOPA studies. Additionally, API RP 752 and 753 guidelines address facility siting and personnel protection considerations that often integrate with LOPA assessments.

Many industries use these standards as benchmarks for their safety management systems:

  • Oil and gas processing facilities
  • Chemical manufacturing plants
  • Pharmaceutical production units
  • Food processing operations
  • Power generation facilities

 

Each industry sector may adapt LOPA requirements to address their specific operational needs while maintaining consistency with established safety principles. Regular updates to these standards ensure that safety practices evolve alongside technological advancements and lessons learned from industry experiences.

The Sigma-HSE Advantage

Our expert consultants apply a practical strategy that draws on our decades of plant experience and in-depth understanding of published industry norms to perform a LOPA of your facility. We ensure thorough hazard scenario assessment while maintaining alignment with industry standards and regulatory requirements.

Ready to enhance your facility’s safety through expert LOPA implementation? Contact our team today for a consultation. Our specialists will help you identify optimization opportunities and develop effective risk reduction strategies tailored to your needs. Call us at [Phone Number] or fill out our contact form below to get started.

Request a Layers of Protection Analysis (LOPA) Quote

Sigma-HSE uses the contact information provided to contact you. You may unsubscribe from our communications via a link at the bottom of our emails at any time. Our privacy policy and our commitment to the protection of your privacy is outlined in our Privacy Statement.
We would like to share details of our work, webinars you can attend, insights, case studies and fact sheets with you. To do this, we need to hold some of your personal information, including your full name, job title, organisation name and email address.

Frequently asked questions

LOPA is a risk assessment methodology that evaluates safeguards in hazard scenarios. It provides a numerical analysis of risks by examining initiating events, enabling factors, and independent protection layers to determine if additional safety measures are needed.

If your facility has conducted a PHA and has scenarios that are high risk, have recommendations that have a high capital cost, or if you’d like to see a more calculated assessment of scenarios, a LOPA allows for a more detailed approach to hazardous scenarios to ensure the risk is appropriately calculated and recommendations meet the level of risk reduction required.

The values used can come from Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS) literature, company information on failure rates of equipment, manufacturer ratings for failure on demand, and other literature sources.

While PHA identifies potential hazards and their consequences, LOPA provides a more detailed, quantitative assessment of specific high-risk scenarios identified during the PHA. LOPA helps determine if existing safeguards provide adequate risk reduction.

Organizations typically conduct LOPA studies:

  • After completing a Process Hazard Analysis
  • When evaluating new process safety systems
  • During major facility modifications
  • When assessing high-risk scenarios
  • For compliance with safety regulations

Independent protection layers are safeguards that can prevent or mitigate hazardous events. Each layer must:

  • Be independent of other protection layers
  • Be capable of preventing the hazardous event
  • Be auditable through testing or inspection
  • Have a quantifiable probability of failure

LOPA calculates risk reduction by:

  1. Determining initiating event frequency
  2. Evaluating enabling event probabilities
  3. Assessing the effectiveness of each protection layer
  4. Comparing the final risk level to acceptable risk criteria

A LOPA study requires:

  • Process flow diagrams
  • Hazard and operability study results
  • Equipment specifications
  • Maintenance records
  • Incident history
  • Operating procedures
  • Safety system documentation

Organizations should review and update their LOPA studies:

  • Every 3-5 years
  • After significant process changes
  • Following major incidents
  • When implementing new safety systems
  • During facility expansions
safety minute HAZID HAZOP

If you find yourself asking, ‘Do I need a LOPA at my facility?’, connect with us today. One of our subject matter experts will guide you through any questions you may have.

For businesses in the EU or UK, or for those wishing to comply with DSEAR/ATEX Directives, please click here to find out more on our dedicated DSEAR Risk Assessment or ATEX Compliance pages.

 

Enhance safety through our LOPA solutions, meticulously analyzing protective layers to uncover and address potential risks

Protect business, people, workplace and the environment from potentially unsafe equipment in hazardous zones and comply with explosive atmospheres regulations. Learn more about how we can assist you today.

Are you visiting Sigma-HSE from outside your region? Visit your regional site for more relevant process safety solutions.